How To Reheat Papa John’s Pizza?

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

Papa John’s Pizza is one of the most famous pizza brands in the world. The taste, toppings, sauce, and texture are all unique and delicious.

Everyone, right from students to working professionals, love pizza and can have them anytime, for breakfast, lunch, or even dinner.

Best Way to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

There’s nothing like a warm slice of Papa John’s Pizza on a lazy afternoon. However, if you have to store it for later, you will have to reheat it properly to preserve its taste. Here we have listed some of the easiest and best methods to reheat Papa John’s Pizza so that it tastes warm and crispy on the outside.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in an Oven?

Yes, you can reheat Papa John’s Pizza in an oven which is the best way to reheat it evenly. Start by preheating the oven to 450 degrees before you start reheating for 5 to 10 minutes. An oven may take slightly longer to reheat your pizza as compared to a microwave, but you will end up with perfectly reheated pizza slices.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in a Microwave?

Yes, you can reheat Papa John’s Pizza in the least possible time in a microwave. You can choose to reheat the entire pizza or a slice or two at a time. The trick is to keep a microwave-safe glass full of water next to the pizza so that it doesn’t dry out, heat for 45 to 50 seconds, and you’re ready to serve.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza on the Stove?

Yes, you can reheat Papa John’s Pizza on a stove in very little time. Take out a suitable pan or skillet, and keep the heat medium/low. Place the pizza in the pan and add drops of water on the edges of the pan. Cover and cook for not more than two minutes till the bottom is crunchy and serve immediately.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza on a Grill?

Yes, you can always reheat your pizza on a grill, especially if you like a crispy crust. Warm the grill till medium-hot and place the pizza on top. Reheat for five to seven minutes or until you get a nice, crispy outer layer. Take care of the grill temperature and serve immediately while still hot.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in a Toaster Oven?

It takes very little time to heat Papa John’s Pizza in a toaster oven as compared to an oven. Preheat the oven to 325 degrees Fahrenheit and place a few slices at a time in a baking tray. Reheat for 5 minutes and check the pizza one if you need to reheat for another minute or two before serving hot.

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in an Air Fryer?

Yes, you can reheat Papa John’s Pizza to perfection in an air fryer basket within a few minutes. For best results, preheat the air fryer to 325 degrees Fahrenheit and arrange the pizza slices evenly in the basket.

Reheat the pizza for not more than 5 minutes at a time, check whether done and serve immediately.

How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza Without Overcooking?

For a perfectly reheated pizza, take the slices out of the fridge and bring them to room temperature before reheating. Take care to microwave only for a few seconds at a time; otherwise, your pizza may end up a soggy mess.

A grill or a skillet also needs proper temperature control to avoid burning your favorite pizza.

How Long to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza?

Papa John’s Pizza can be reheated in the preheated oven within 10 minutes, which is the same time you will need to reheat the pizza in a toaster oven. If you’re using a microwave, reheat for a few seconds at a time.

An air fryer requires not more than five minutes, while reheating on a stove or grill would require not more than two to seven minutes respectively.

What Temperature is Needed to Safely Reheat Papa John’s Pizza?

You can safely reheat Papa John’s Pizza at 4500 in a preheated oven or 325 degrees Fahrenheit in a toaster oven for the best results. If you’re using an air fryer, preheat the oven and reheat for 325 degrees Fahrenheit until done. A stove or a grill provides direct heating, so you will have to make sure that the grill or skillet doesn’t get too hot.

Although nothing can compare to a freshly cooked pizza, any remaining slices can be easily reheated so that it comes closest to the original taste. Try out these reheating tips to enjoy your Papa John’s Pizza any time.


Make Better Food

Pizza Today