How To Reheat Medium Rare Steak?

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

Medium rare steak is an expensive but delicious item on the menu, and many of them prefer to wrap it back home. But the problem is it does not taste as good as the day when the steak is being prepared.

However, individuals can prefer reheating it to taste and eat hot. But reheating improperly can also affect the steaks, so be careful. This article describes different methods of reheating steaks to avoid chewy, tough and flavorless pieces of meat. 

Best Way to Reheat Medium Rare Steak

Heating medium-rare steak again in the Microwave is a suitable way. Just throw the pieces and turn on the appliance for two minutes. Before doing so, you should set the Microwave at medium heat and heat at intervals of 30 seconds.

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak in an Oven?

If anyone wishes to have juicy steak, warming up the pieces of meat in an oven can be a great idea. Firstly, you have to preheat the oven, and the temperature to maintain is 275 degrees F. 

Take a large baking sheet and keep a wire cooling rack. It allows the hot air to circulate throughout the steak leading to even heating. Put the meat pieces on the top cooling rack and reduce the temperature to 110 degrees F. 

Then warm-up for at least 30 minutes based on the thickness of the meat pieces. Take a tablespoon of oil and spread over the steak, and cook both sides for one minute each, and it’s ready. 

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak in a Microwave?

Throw the pieces of steak in the Microwave and follow the below steps to get them. Remember not to haphazardly place them as it will make them chewy and dry. 

While microwaving, take a plate and put a damp paper towel over it. Set the Microwave to medium heat and cook at 30 seconds intervals. Increase the time if you think the meat piece is big.

Flip onto the other side and cook properly. Reheating in intervals will avoid overcooking. With that, you can have a full of flavor and juicy steak. 

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak on the Stove?

Reheating on the stove is considered to be a convenient way as many of them have it. Take out the meat steak from the refrigerator. After that, let them settle at room temperature. 

Take a pan and let it heat up at low to medium flame. After it is warm, you can add a splash of beef stock. It will make the leftover juicier. Cover the pan and allow them to boil at a low flame for a couple of minutes. 

Check after a few minutes to avoid overcooking and sticking to the base. After reheating, you can take out the steak from the pan and serve it hot. 

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak on a Grill?

Steak can be reheated on a grill for which you have to keep the meat pieces out to settle at room temperature. After that, let the grill heat up at low flame and then put some oil and heat the steak

Sprinkle some water or beef stock and cover the stock. In between, you have to check to avoid sticking to the base of the grill. Take the pieces out when cooking is done. 

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak in a Toaster Oven?

Warming up medium-rare steaks is also possible in a toaster oven. For that, you have to set the oven at 275 degrees F and preheat for some time. After that, place the food on a tray and put them into the cooking appliance. 

While heating, you should reduce the temperature to 100 degrees F and then cook for 20 to 30 minutes.

Can You Reheat Medium Rare Steak in an Air Fryer?

You can reheat steak in an Air fryer for three to five minutes at 100 to 130 degrees F. Sprinkle some oil over the meat and warm for one minute on each side, and it’s ready.

How to Reheat Medium Rare Steak Without Overcooking?

Reheating without overheating is possible by setting the time in increments. Also, while cooking on the stove, you should check now and then. 

How Long to Reheat Medium Rare Steak?

The time to reheat depends on the thickness of the meat. It can be 20 to 30 minutes in an oven or a microwave. 

What Temperature is Needed to Safely Reheat Medium Rare Steak?

For preheating, the temperature should be 275 degrees F, and warming can be from 100 to 130 degrees F. Pick up any method to reheat medium-rare steak, keep the temperature and time, and go for it.


All Recipes

Cooks Illustrated