How To Reheat Deep Dish Pizza?

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

Deep dish pizza, famously known as Chicago- style pizza, is utterly delicious and easy to cook. You’ll be absolutely full in one serve, thanks to the ‘more than normal’ toppings and oozing cheese.

There’s no way you’ll be able to finish the cheesy monster in one go. We’ve got you covered by curating an article to help you with different methods of reheating deep dish pizza.

Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza

The best way to reheat deep dish pizza is under controlled temperature with adequate moisture to retain the creaminess of cheese and softness of the crust. The oven is by far the best to reheat pizza as loaded as a Chicago-style one.

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza in an Oven?

To maintain the creamy texture of cheese, simultaneously warming up the crust and toppings is the best to do in an oven. Preheat the oven to a temperature of 350° F. Place the leftover pizza in a tray or dish, whatever is available and suits you the best.

To make the process easier, you may cut the pizza in slices too. At the side of the tray, place an oven-safe cup full of water. Let the water and pizza stay in for 20 minutes.

The extra water will keep the oven interior moist, keeping the cheese from becoming stringy and chewy. It will also prevent the stiffening of the crust. Do not touch the dish with bare hands; always use oven mitts and wait for the pizza to cool a bit before consuming.

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza in a Microwave?

The microwave method is perfect for quickly reheating a few slices of deep-dish pizza. If you’re planning on reheating the whole thing, you might end with a stiff crust and chewy cheese. We suggest you slice down the pizza and microwave two slices at a time.

Put the deep dish pizza slices on a microwave-safe plate and set the timer for 10 minutes. Let the slices reheat and check once at a five-minute interval. The cheese might get overheated, but you’d have to give it time to reheat the inner toppings. Enjoy with fries and cola!

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza on the Stove?

The stove might be the last option for you, but there’s quite a chance that the pizza would lose its balanced texture. The stove might not be suitable for reheating all of it. You may slice up the pizza for fairly better results.

Use a thick-bottomed skillet and place the slices on it over low flame. Sprinkle some water over and cover it with a lid. The rising steam will reheat the pizza from the insides; however, it’s not a guarantee.

You can line the skillet with aluminum foil to prevent the pizza base from burning. For best results, we would suggest you skip this method and try out the other reheating methods mentioned.

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza on a Grill?

The grill will be best if you wish to relish on a plate full of burnt pizza. We do not recommend using the grill for reheating pizza at all. Use the other methods mentioned for the best results.

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza in a Toaster Oven?

Much like an oven, preheat the toaster oven at 350°F and line a tray with pizza slices. Cover it all with aluminum foil and place the pizza to reheat for 15 minutes. The foil covering will keep the cheese from burning, and the even distribution of heat will warm up the whole deep-dish pizza.

Can You Reheat Deep Dish Pizza in an Air Fryer?

Cut the pizza into pieces that would fit in the air frying basket. Spray some cooking oil in it or line it with aluminum foil to avoid sticking. Place the small slices in the basket and heat for 10 minutes. The hot air coming out of the air fryer will reheat the slices thoroughly.

Although there’s quite a chance that the pizza might become chewy and dry, you can consume it with some drink to tone down the dryness.

How to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza Without Overcooking?

To avoid overcooking the deep dish pizza, use the ways we’ve mentioned accordingly. Do not expose the pizza to direct high heat for more than 5 minutes. Sprinkle some water over it before reheating to keep the ingredients from getting charred.

How Long to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza?

Don’t heat the pizza for more than 15 minutes unless mentioned in the article. The pizza might come out dry and stiff. Follow the instructions word to word.

What Temperature is Needed to Safely Reheat Deep Dish Pizza?

The perfect temperature to reheat deep dish pizza is 350° F. It ensures that the pizza does not get overcooked or burnt. You can always decide on the duration according to your observation.



The Windup Space

Kitchen Guider