5 Best Toasters for English Muffins (Reviews Updated 2022)

If you want a simple breakfast, English muffins will do a great job of filling up your belly. They are yeast-risen and not baked as most people think; rather, they are griddled. They are made by pouring the batter into a ring mold sitting on a grill. After it browns on one side, it is then flipped on the other side.

But then, if you want to toast your English muffins, you will need one of the best toasters for English muffins. They will give you the exact shade you want your muffin to be and leave the insides just as fluffy as you like it.

There are a lot of toasters you can choose from. But then, only a few of them will offer you wonderfully toast English muffins. We have compiled and reviewed five (5) of the best toasters for English muffins available on the market. Read them below.

Best Toaster for English Muffins

Want to learn more?

Here are our Best Toaster for English Muffins reviews.

1. Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Toaster

If you fancy a 2-in-1 toaster, we recommend the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 for you. It features 4 toasting slots which are 1.5-inch wide and large enough to fit your English muffins conveniently. The toaster carriage of this unit pops up when the toasting is done. Perhaps you find it difficult to remove small pieces from the toaster; you can use the high-lift lever. For frozen English muffins, simply use the defrost setting, which defrosts and toasts it. Be aware that this might take a longer time than usual.

Other settings that this toaster offers include the bagel settings, the reheating function that warms up your food with low heat, and the normal toasting settings. If you wish to cancel the operation at any time, simply press the cancel button. No crumb is going to litter your countertop because the removable crumb tray will collect all of it for easy disposal.

Why do we like it?

• Comes with an instruction book
• Convenient cord storage
• BPA free

Check Price on Amazon

2. Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster

If you prefer some automation, you’ll like the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless toaster. Simply press the toast button and watch your food lower into the chamber. We are impressed with the fact that once toasting is done to your preferred shade, it makes a beep and comes out without any other button being pressed. Two control panels offer the flexibility of giving your English muffins different shades at the same time. 7 different shade settings are available for you to choose from. The nice part is that you can set the shade digitally.

Apart from English muffins, this versatile toaster conveniently defrosts and toast frozen pancakes, bagel, thick and thin French toast, and reheats cold pastries. With the accurate countdown timer, you can precisely determine when your toast will be ready. This perfect blend of technology and design makes this toaster for English muffins a must-have for your kitchen countertop.

Why do we like it?

• Outstanding performance
• 3-year warranty
• Easy to use

Check Price on Amazon

3. Wolf Gourmet WGTR122S Toaster

You need some extra-wide slots to fit your thick English muffins? The Wolf Gourmet with its 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot will suffice. With self-centering slots, It will brown whatever food you put in evenly and raise it out automatically after the toasting cycle is completed. It has a dedicated keep warm setting that reheats your English muffins without browning them more. For precise control over the operations, the Wolf Gourmet sports a shade selector dial that allows you to choose between light and dark shades of toast. With its stainless steel and die-cast construction, you can be assured of durability.

For frozen English muffins, it requires only one push of a button to defrost and toast them to your preferred shade. Note that this might take a little longer than the usual toasting time. To prevent crumbs of food from littering your countertop, a removable crumb tray is present at the bottom of the unit to make clean-up easier.

Why do we like it?

• Commercial heating elements
• Highly versatile
• 5 year limited warranty

Check Price on Amazon

4. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set Toaster

When you need a toaster for English muffins that looks good on your countertop and offers you exceptional performance, go for the KRUPS KH734D. It features dual independent control panels. This offers you the flexibility of toasting 2 – 4 English muffins to different shades simultaneously. Remarkably, the 4 slots available on this toaster are extra large and exhibits a self-centering mechanism. 4 different buttons performing separate functions allow your morning toasting routine to be seamless. For frozen food, simply use the defrosting button. If you want to reheat your English muffins without further browning, press the reheat button.

There is also a dedicated button for bagels. Peradventure, you want to stop the toasting process immediately; the cancel button does this instantly. You can choose your preferred shade with the 6 browning settings ranging from light to very dark. More so, the design of this unit is user-friendly.

Why do we like it?

• High-lift lever
• Made with brushed and chrome stainless steel
• Highly durable

Check Price on Amazon

5. Oster 2-Slice Toaster

Save a lot of space with the Oster 2-Slice toaster for English muffins. Measuring only 11.7 x 6.9 x 7.3-inches, it will sit comfortably at a small corner on your countertop. It might be small, but it performs incredibly well. Due to the Advanced Toasting Technology and auto-adjusting bread guides it features, you will get evenly toast English muffins every time. The small size only allows the availability of 2 slots. Notwithstanding, these 2 slots are extra-wide to accommodate the thickness of your English muffins. This unit has settings for frozen food, bagels, and pastries.

One nice thing we noticed is that each setting has its own customizable toasting time, which aims to give you perfect results always. Simply use the 7-shade settings dial to customize your toast to your most preferred shade. Its anti-jamming mechanism prevents jamming, and the control panel is user-friendly.

Why do we like it?

• Smudge-proof
• Improved temperature control
• Features a high-rise lever

Check Price on Amazon