5 Best Sour Cream Substitutes (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

Sour cream is one of the most acceptable dairy products utilized in many food items. It is often used as an ingredient or with a combination of some food. It isn’t very pleasant when you are in the middle of making something, and you find out you don’t have a sour cream in your fridge. Often it becomes frustrating a time-consuming to go to the market and buy it.

But you don’t have to worry now because you won’t have to go anywhere to buy a sour cream if you run out of it. We have come up with some of the best sour cream substitutes that will work as a substitute and enhance your food flavoring and quality. So read this article till the end to find out some of the best sour cream substitutes.

Best Sour Cream Substitutes

Want to know more?

Here are our best sour cream substitute reviews.

1. Happy Belly Cream Cheese

Happy Belly Cream Cheese

Cream cheese comes in an eight oz packet and contains no artificial flavors or preservatives. It is completely made up of natural and organic products. The best replacement for sour cream is cream cheese by happy belly. It will not only act as a substitute but also enhance your food’s flavor and odor.

The cream cheese is thick and has great consistency. You can use it in several recipes, such as making the white sauce, milk, pasta, etc. it works best at room temperature, and only about one or two tablespoons would be enough to be used in the food items. The specialty of the cream cheese is that it melts down completely and forms a uniform consistency of your food, merging well in every food.

If you run out of sour cream, don’t worry, cream cheese got your back and will not fail to make your dish completely perfect and delicious.  Sour cream is less thick than cream cheese, so mixing the cream cheese well in food will make food more appealing and favorable. The cream cheese is purely made up of high-quality goat or cow milk, which is very beneficial for health.

Why do we like it?

  • Natural
  • Health friendly
  • No preservatives add
Check Price on Amazon


2. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Buttermilk

365 By Whole Foods Market Organic Buttermilk

Buttermilk is also one of the great substitutes for sour cream. It comes at an affordable price and is creamy. It can be used in various food items such as salads, white sauce, etc. the buttermilk will give a light and creamy flavor and taste to your food that you would surely like to eat. If you want to use buttermilk as a replacement for sour cream, add three by fourth cup of it in the preparation. Due to its creamy nature, it is thick and has great consistency.

Having buttermilk in your food will make the dish more loaded and fulfilling. You can create sauces and dips by adding buttermilk to them. Buttermilk tastes almost similar to sour cream, so you won’t have to face a greater difference in taste.  This high-quality and healthy buttermilk is easy to use and add as it comes in a bottle that is easy to pour. It can be stored at room temperature or in the freezer. The ingredients of buttermilk include flour, coffee, organic milk, and some veggies. With such loaded ingredients comes great taste.

Why do we like it?

  • Similar taste
  • Thick consistency
  • Affordable
Check Price on Amazon


3. Lifeway Organic Kefir

Lifeway Organic Kefir

Organic kefir contains a thirty-two oz bottle of low-fat and plain milk. It is called the best dairy drink and can be used as a sour cream substitute. Rich in protein and calcium and has probiotic cultures. Having probiotic culture means it boosts the immune system and promotes digestive system health.

It contains about 110kcal and 11 g of proteins, so as we can see, it has many health benefits and works as a substitute. It is an excellent choice to be added in sauce making, dips, smoothies. One can consume directly from the packet. 99% lactose ad gluten-free drink. Contains all the organic and non-GMO products. Being free from lactose means it contains no allergies so that every individual can consume it freely.

Made up of all-natural and organic ingredients, also contains some sweeteners and preservatives. It is made up of goat or cow’s milk. Add a little amount of kefir instead of sour milk, and you will get the best and new taste of your dish and surely want to consume it more often. Kefir is thicker than sour cream, and only adding a small amount will fulfill the need for sour cream.

Why do we like it?

  • Organic
  • Plain milk
  • Rich in proteins
Check Price on Amazon


4. Vermont Creamery Crème Fraiche

Vermont Creamery Crème Fraiche

Crème Fraiche is French cream that can be used as a substitute for sour cream. It is slightly less sour than the original sour cream.  It has a thick consistency and has an extra rich and creamy texture, which will make your dish juicier and more delicious. Crème Fraiche is thickly cultured with a taste of nutty flavor.

Being gluten-free in nature, it can be consumed by everyone. It is perfect to be used in soups, salads, as dips, or many more. One of the best features is it will not thicken when heated or mixed in lemon juice.   Vermont crème Fraiche comes in 8 oz in a small box.  Made up of organic milk of cow, with highly thick and creamy consistency can be used in the very food item.

Consisting of rich taste and unique properties which enhances every dish it is utilized. As crème Fraiche is less sour than coir cream, so adds twice the amount of it in the food item to get the same result and taste. It has no preservatives o extra flavors added to it. So this product comes out to be natural and organic.

Why do we like it?

  • Organic
  • Les sour
  • Nutty flavor
Check Price on Amazon


5. Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise

Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise

Hellmann’s real mayonnaise is rich in omega-three fatty acids, containing 650 mg of it. It is primarily gluten-free. Mayo gets unfavorable criticism, yet it is, in any case, an incredible acrid cream substitute. It tends to be utilized as a 1:1 substitution in both heating and plunges. You’ll lose a portion of that tang that sharp cream offers.

However, it works effectively at adding dampness to prepared products. Besides, it’s generally a similar surface as sharp cream, which makes it an extraordinary sub in plunges and sauce. Utilize a combo of mayonnaise and yogurt to get a portion of the tartness back. Here’s a fixing you most likely have available: mayonnaise!

You can utilize it as a cup-for-cup swap for acrid cream in many plans—including heated merchandise! (Mayo adds a huge load of dampness to things like cakes and biscuits since it’s produced using eggs and oil.) Likewise, it can fill in as a garnish—treat it with a sprinkle of apple juice vinegar to give it a touch of tang. It is made up of oil, eggs, salt, sugar, vinegar, lemon juice and natural flavors.


Why do we like it?

  • Contains omega-three fatty acids
  • Gluten-free
  • Organic
Check Price on Amazon


Sour Cream Substitute Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to buying the best sour cream substitute, as you can see, we have the various option so selecting the best one is not such an easy task to do. One needs to look for many such factors to have the best substitute. Here are some of the factors you must consider while buying the best one that fits into your recipes well.

Dairy product

The substitute made up of dairy products is the best one to consume. But if you are allergic to dairy products, you can opt for non-dairy substitutes. Most of the dairy substitutes are gluten and lactose-free, so easily everyone can consume them. They are more organic and natural and have more health benefits.  Dairy products have fewer preservatives added to them, which makes them a great choice.


The more consistent the product is, the more it will provide taste and flavor to the food. Some of the more consistent substitutes are mayonnaise, cheese, and buttermilk. These provide more consistency to your food items. A small amount of addition is vital to fulfilling all the needs and requirements. Consistency impacts the texture of food.

Natural product

The products that make up a substitute are also very important. The natural products include organic milk, lemon, etc. all the artificial sweeteners and preservation-free items are healthy to consume. They have more self-life and can be used for a long period. Along with this, they have more health benefits. The more organic the products will be the healthier friendly it will be.


Substitutes are not such a thing that should be bought at a very high price. Opt for substitutes that are cheap or at least are affordable. This is because they are not daily but are used sometimes in little amount. So, it won’t be wise to buy an expensive sour substitute to meet your needs. So, you don’t have to go for an expensive one when affordable ones are already available.