Best Sandwich Toaster

5 Best Sandwich Toasters (Reviews Updated 2021)

If you love sandwiches, a sandwich toaster is a must-have for your kitchen. But before buying one, you need to understand the difference between a sandwich maker and a sandwich toaster. Well, for starters, a sandwich maker is much more versatile than a sandwich toaster. A sandwich toaster is only meant to toast your sandwiches and doesn’t allow you to add any fillings.

While on the other hand, a sandwich maker can prepare other snacks like eggs, biscuits and mix cheese. A sandwich toaster has its advantages. People have become prone to buying a sandwich toaster nowadays. Are you looking forward to adding one to your kitchen? We searched all the best sandwich makers in the market and listed our best options below.

Best Sandwich Toasters

Want to learn more?

Here are our best sandwich toasters’ reviews.

1. Cuisinart GR-300WS Griddler Elite

Cuisinart Gr 300ws Griddler Elite

This amazing toaster has got six toasting functions. Its sleek stainless steel design makes it look so beautiful and sober that it can go with any kitchen décor. If we talk about dimensions, it has got two plates widened to 240 square inches. So you can easily prepare a couple of steaks, eggs or cook two to three sandwiches at the same time.

It has a feature of dual-zone temperature control that enables you to cook/roast two different things at two different temperatures simultaneously. This means you can heat a steak on one plate and roast a sandwich on the other simultaneously. This feature saves you quite a lot of time. Its plates are removable, non-stick, and reversible, which means the clean-up will be an easy task. You can safely put it in the dishwasher.

Why do we like it?

  • Six cooking functions
  • Large capacity
  • Dual-zone temperature feature
Check Price on Amazon


2. George Foreman Sandwich Toaster

George Foreman Sandwich Toaster

If you want more than just sandwiches from your sandwich toaster, the George Foreman toaster is ideal. You can make toasted sandwiches, Paninis, or a large baguette, all in this one model. It has 12 x 12 x 6.5 inches dimensions, which can squeeze the giant sandwich and toast it easily. The best part about this toaster is that it heats 35% faster than other usual sandwich toasters.

Its removable trays make the task of clean-up quite easy. Although the George Foreman sandwich toaster is not the smallest model to make it into our list, it is still very compact, and you can take it anywhere easily. It will not acquire much of the space on your counter, and a smart and sleek design will add a nice touch to your kitchen’s décor.

Why do we like it?

  • Good value
  • Faster heat up
  • Compact design
Check Price on Amazon


3. Yoshikawa ATSU-ATSU Sandwich Toaster

Yoshikawa Atsu Atsu Sandwich Toaster

This sandwich toaster is a lot different from the other models discussed in the list. It comes from a Japanese company called Yoshikawa. This company is renowned for its electrical home appliances. This model comes in handy if you don’t have much of the space on your countertop. Its compact design makes it easy to utilize and saves you space as well. If you are looking for a model to take with you on traveling, you can consider this pick.

It has no complicated heating controls, which makes it easy to use. Some sandwich toasters require pre-heating your food before putting them inside the toaster, which is not the case here. You can directly put your food in the toaster without preheating. You can fix your sandwich on the tray, cover it with an upper tray for protection, and start cooking it over your stove.

Why do we like it?

  • Small-sized
  • Durable
  • Easy clean
Check Price on Amazon


4. Hamilton Beach Sandwich Toaster

Hamilton Beach Sandwich Toaster

If you like eggs in the fixings of your toasted sandwich, this toaster can help you. It has dual cooking plates. These plates allow you to cook your sandwich in two different parts. Let’s say some ham and cheese in the upper part and an egg in the lower part. It has a five minutes timer that reminds you when your food is done with an audible beep. Then you can slide the plate out without damaging the arrangement of your sandwich.

Its most noticeable feature is that it enables you to toast two different sandwiches with different ingredients simultaneously. Find clean-up of your toaster difficult? You don’t have to worry anymore. This HAMILTON BEACH SANDWICH TOASTER comes with removable plates so that you can take the plates out and put them in the dishwasher as they are dishwasher safe. Moreover, it has indicator lights that show you if your toaster is pre-heated or turned on.

Why do we like it?

  • Ideal for cooking muffins and eggs
  • Removable plates
  • Dual plates for cooking
Check Price on Amazon


5. Sage The Perfect Press Sandwich Maker

Sage The Perfect Press Sandwich Maker

Sage sandwich toaster topped our list of best sandwich toasters because of its superb functionalities available at such a reasonable price. It is not as versatile as the other models discussed in this list, but it is best at what it’s meant for. The system heats rapidly thanks to the 1500 watt power supply, which means you will not have to wait so long for your sandwiches to be done. You get your meal prepared in two to three minutes.

The plates are quite easy to clean due to the PFOA-free non-stick coating. Since the plates are not removable, you cannot directly put them in the dishwasher. If you go out a lot, this sandwich maker suits you because of its compact design. It only secures a small place in your cabinet. It is also very easy to utilize and has a cool-touch handle that prevents your hands from burning.

Why do we like it?

  • Doesn’t squash sandwiches
  • Compact
  • Reasonable price
Check Price on Amazon


Sandwich Toasters Buyer’s Guide

Sandwich toasters arrive with different features. Unlike sandwich makers, not all sandwich toasters can satisfy all users. But the job would be easier if you break down the features into a list and then decide what features you need the most in your sandwich toaster. You can choose between a model that can toast your sandwiches or a model that can further be used to serve up stacked sandwiches, grill meat, or cook waffles. Following are some things to explore before you go looking to buy a sandwich toaster for your kitchen.


Size matters a lot when you go to buy a sandwich toaster. If you do a lot of toasting, you will need a sandwich toaster with larger dimensions to toast three to four sandwiches at a time. But if the case is the opposite, spending extra money on buying a sandwich toaster with larger dimensions can be foolish. Most of the users prefer small dimensions as they are easy to utilize. But, again, it is up to you. You can choose the right size depending on your needs.

Basic or Multifunctional

Some sandwich toasters offer just the basic toasting function, while the others arrive with amazing extra features like panini press. For example, some of the models have a defrost option. This option allows you to defrost your frozen bread and then toast it. It can save you a lot of time and energy. On some models, this feature comes with the name “frozen.” A reheat mode can come in handy if you want your toast warm without doing all the handwork.

Price and Warranty

Most people look at the price very first before buying anything. Today, many companies make sandwich toasters, but you cannot randomly choose one, as we discussed. A product’s quality is dependent upon its price. You can find slice toasters under $200, $100, and $50 but it is better to spend a little more and buy a good quality toaster than saving a few dollars and then suffering later.

In our list, we have featured both cheap and expensive high-end sandwich toasters, so it’s easy for you to choose a pocket-friendly model. Moreover, most companies cover their toasters with a warranty of at least a year or two. So be sure to keep this in mind too while buying.