Best Pan For Baking Cookies

5 Best Pans for Baking Cookies (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.
We all love cookies, at least most of us do, but none of us likes a badly made cookie. For cookies to taste right, two things are involved; the ingredients and the quality of the baking pan. Cookies that are made with the best pan for baking cookies not only look right, they also feel right and taste right.

The good news is that there are so many cookie pan brands online these days; the bad news is that many of them are inferior pans that don’t represent value for money. So, the last thing we want is for you to fall prey to low-quality pans that will ruin your cookies every time you bake them. To this end, we have decided to scan the internet for you. So, find below some of the best pan for baking cookies. We are sure that you will find a very good option for your oven among our selection.

Best Pan for Baking Cookies

Want to learn more?

Here are our Best Pan for Baking Cookies Reviews.

1. Farberware Bakeware Cookie Baking Sheet

Farberware Bakeware Cookie Baking Sheet

This Farberware is a great selection for your cookies for several reasons. Firstly, comes in 3 sheets per package. This means that you have more than enough sheet space to bake as many cookies as you want. Secondly, the sheet is nonstick. This is great news because it allows you to clean the sheet when you are done baking. Furthermore, you will not lose any part of your dough to the sheet.

The sheet is gray, which is just the right color for a cookie pan. But above all, this pan is very durable. It will not crack, warp, or rust. There are no hot spots associated with Farberware. So what you see is what you get, my friend. Quality all, through.

Might we also add that Farberware is wide with a 9×23 inches width for the largest sheet and slightly smaller sizes for the other two pans

Why do we like it?

  • High heat pans
  • Anti-warp features
  • Lightweight
Check Price on Amazon


2. Farberware Nonstick Cookie Pan

Farberware Nonstick Cookie Pan

Another Fareberware Pan to make our list is this durable nonstick high heat bakeware that can serve as a sheet and a pan. It is very strong with very durable construction. With this bakeware, you can roast, toast, and bake food just how you like it. More importantly, it is very useful for baking cookies of different sizes due to its expansive size.

Standing at 10×15 inches, the surface can accommodate so many cookies at once, which is great news if you prefer to bake so many cookies at once. With this bakeware, your cookies will not get burnt, neither will they stick to the surface. Removing them is easy and maintaining them afterward is great news.

If you must buy the best pan for baking cookies, make sure you go for one that is of high quality. With Farberware, you can’t go wrong.

Why do we like it?

  • Flat base
  • Food safe coat
  • High heat retention
  • Easy to clean
Check Price on Amazon


3. Racheal Ray 3-Piece Bakeware Set

Racheal Ray 3 Piece Bakeware

The best pan for baking cookies hardly comes in single units, but multiple units, and this Racheal Ray 3-Piece Bakeware set is a good example of baking pans that offer real value. Should you go for this set, be assured that you are getting a set that will offer you an excellent return on your investment. All the units in this set are nonstick, and they come in different sizes.

This allows you to bake small or large-sized cookies, and you can bake as many as you want per batch. The only thing you will have to worry about is your oven’s capacity. Additionally, the units have grip handles that allow you to carry them out of the oven even when they are very hot. The steel gauges used in making them are heat resistant and of the highest quality.

This Racheal Ray Bakeware set is an excellent utensil for baking tasty cookies that your kids will love.

Why do we like it?

  • Lightweight but durable
  • Heat resistant
  • Easy to remove your cookies from the nonstick surface
Check Price on Amazon


4. TeamFar Cookie Baking Set of 2 Pan & Sheet

Teamfar Cookie Baking Set Of 2 Pan & Sheet

This TeamFar Cookie Baking sheet and pan are an excellent combination for your baking exercise. They are made from non-toxic stainless steel, so they will not crack or lose form even when exposed to intense heat. The exterior is made from rust-free and mirror finish stainless steel. We rate this utensil highly because it is very easy to use and clean. They are both dishwasher safe which is another plus if you want to avoid a set that you have to clean with maximum effort.

The exquisite craftsmanship is another thing we like about this brand. Due to the appealing look of the set, you can choose to use it to serve food at your dinner table. So, therefore, buying TeamFar offers you good value in and out of your kitchen.

TeamFar is a great replacement for your aluminum pans because it is far durable and safer.

Why do we like it?

  • Heavy-duty build
  • Ideal for mass baking
  • Multifunctional
  • Even heat distribution
Check Price on Amazon


5. Anolon Advanced Nonstick Cookie Bakeware

Anolon Advanced Nonstick Cookie Bakeware

Last but not least on our review of the best pan for baking cookies is this Anolon Advanced Nonstick bakeware with sturdy grip handles. The manufacturer constructed the sheets with your comfort in mind. First and foremost, this sheet will not burn your cookies, neither will they be hard to remove. It has a nonstick bakeware surface that you will appreciate because it guarantees you even cookie release.

Anolon is quite expansive with a 10×15 inches size giving you sufficient baking space. As for lifting, you will have it easy lifting the sheet from your oven by simply holding on to the handles on both sides.

With even heat distribution guaranteed, your cookies will always come out right with Anolon every time you use it.

Why do we like it?

  • Even browning of your cookies
  • Advanced heat transfer
  • Multifunctional feature
Check Price on Amazon


Best Pan for Baking Cookies

You need to consider a number of things when shopping for the best pan for baking cookies. Very good spring foam pans or tart pans may work well under high heat, but they are not as wide as cookie pans. So, therefore, the things you will consider when shopping for a cookie pan or sheet are not the same things you will consider when shopping for other types of pans. We review some essential factors to consider when making a selection.

Oven Size

You need to consider the size of your oven when making a selection. The last thing you want is to go for a pan that is too big for your oven. So, we advise that you get the correct measurement of your oven first before buying a pan. If your oven is too small, but you still insist on buying bakeware, consider buying pyrex baking dishes or a pizza pan.


We always educate our readers on the importance of safety. This is why we recommend pans that have handles. So make sure the pan you are looking to buy has sturdy handles made of silicone, like some of the best silicone baking pans.


How much you pay for the best pan for baking cookies will depend on the number of units in the set and the quality. While it pays to go for the best quality, we advise that you go for what you can afford.