5 Best Mustards for Sandwiches (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

You cannot deny the importance of mustard if you are a foodie. Mustard usually sits next to the ketchup in the cabinet and is often used along with it. Buying good-quality mustard is not a difficult task. But if your main concern is sandwiches, you will have to put some effort into the buying area. When you go looking in a store aisle, you will see that a huge number of brands are making mustards nowadays. But you cannot just rely on any brand. It is better to know that the experts approve the product in the field.

You can choose from a variety of mustards that are meant to be used with sandwiches. So if you are looking forward to adding one to your collection, you’re just at the right place.

Best Mustard For Sandwiches

Want to learn more?

Here are our best sandwich mustards’ reviews.

1. French’s Yellow Mustard

French's Yellow Mustard

First on our list is French’s 12 Oz yellow mustard. This brown mustard is quite affordable. French’s 12 Oz Brown Mustard weighs about 1.65 pounds and comes with dimensions of 5.6 x 3.8 x 3 inches. This brown mustard is quite delicious; it is not too tart nor too hot.

Because of its high-quality and premium packaging, this product is worth every penny. In addition, it has a bold and unmistakably big flavor. You can use this brown mustard to make sandwiches, burgers, hot dogs, fries, and many more. This product is just yummy without any bitterness and has a kick. This brand has been providing this mouth-watering brown mustard with the same amazing quality for more than 50-years.

Why do we like it?

  • Durable Packaging
  • Inexpensive
  • Gluten-Free
Check Price on Amazon


2. Sir Kensington’s Spicy Brown Mustard

Sir Kensington's Spicy Brown Mustard

Sir Kensington’s brown mustard is a combination of vinegar and unique old spices. This mustard is quite healthy; it is completely gluten-free and doesn’t have any MSG, fillers, or artificial flavors. In addition, this mustard is kosher, contains zero grams of fat, and has low calories. Furthermore, this product has less vinegar and more particulates, allowing the real flavor to shine through.

It is made with pure mustard seeds. Regardless of its high quality, a pack of six 9-oz bottles of this brown mustard is shockingly inexpensive and worth every penny. Sir Kensington’s brown mustard weighs about 9 ounces. The pack of six ensures that it entertains all your needs if you have a huge family.

Why do we like it?

  • Healthy and Gluten-Free
  • Unmatched Taste
  • All-Natural Ingredients
Check Price on Amazon


3. Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard

Gulden's Spicy Brown Mustard

When it comes to healthy and natural brown mustard, no other brand can beat Gulden. Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard weighs about 12 ounces and has dimensions of 2.02 x 2.93 x 6.4 inches. This mustard is made from a blend of pure and high-quality imported spices and seeds. It is one of the most reviewed brown mustards available in the market, so it’s not just one person who likes it.

Gulden’s Spicy Brown Mustard is quite affordable; a 12-oz bottle of this mustard can cost up to $7. You can use this spicy brown mustard as a topping on pretzels, sandwiches, hot dogs, hamburgers, and many more. This one is perfect for your health; it contains 0-gram trans-fat and five calories per servings.

Why do we like it?

  • Made from Premium Ingredients
  • Affordable Product
  • Durable Packaging
Check Price on Amazon


4. Grey Poupon Dijon Mustard

Grey Poupon Dijon Mustard

Grey Poupon is a french brand and has made its ground after being so long in the field. They are famous for their mustards and ketchup. If you want to save some bucks, then this one is perfect for you. This product contains a pack of 0.5-pound bottles and costs under $5, and due to its high-quality and durable packaging, this item is worth every penny.

With a weight of 0.5 pounds, Grey Poupon’s Spicy mustard is ready to cater to your everyday sandwich needs. This mustard is made from a blend of pure and high-quality imported spices and seeds. It is perfect for your health and contains 0-gram trans-fat and five calories per servings. You can use this spicy brown mustard as a topping on pretzels, sandwiches, hot dogs, hamburgers, and many more.

Why do we like it?

  • Inexpensive and High-Quality
  • Keto-Friendly Snack
  • Sturdy Packaging
Check Price on Amazon


5. Heinz Yellow Mustard

Heinz Yellow Mustard

The name Heinz doesn’t need any introduction when it comes to ketchup and mustards. This brand has been providing high-quality products since 1869. This brown mustard is made from all-natural ingredients, including pure mustard seeds that provide a classic deli flavor. If you have used other Heinz merchandise, you surely know that they are quite tasty and affordable.

Heinz Spicy Brown Mustard weighs about 5.92 pounds and comes with 7 x 6.81 x 7.06 inches. You can use this spicy mustard with your favorite sandwiches, hot dogs, fries, hamburgers, and beyond. On top of that, this product is also kosher certified.

Why do we like it?

  • Convenient Inverted Bottles
  • Kosher Certified
  • Affordable Pack of Six
Check Price on Amazon


Mustard for Sandwiches Buyer’s Guide

Buying mustard is not a difficult task as there are many options available in the market. But not all the mustards go with all types of food items. Each has its specialty area. In our list, we have assembled the mustards that are meant to be used with sandwiches. Choosing the right mustard for sandwiches can be a difficult task.

Spicy Brown and yellow mustards are most common for sandwiches. There are several things you should know before you go looking for mustard. This buyer guide helps you understand different areas to help you choose the mustard that best serves your needs.


Your health is the most important thing in life. Therefore, you should consume healthy meals that contain low fat and calories. An ideal brown mustard bottle has zero fat and up to 5 calories per serving. In addition, your selected product should be gluten-free, kosher certified, and contains no MSG or fillers. You can always find and use nice BBQ sauce as an alternative for your grilled sandwiches and burgers.

Ingredients Used

The final thing that you should look at in the desired mustard that you intend to purchase is the list of all those ingredients used in making that product to ensure that your health is not being compromised in any way. So, for example, check all those Ingredients to make sure that no flavor is added that might harm your health, so be sure to check it. BBQ mustard sauce is a product that you can use as an efficient replacement of mustard, if you are not comfortable with the quality of ingredients used in it.


While shopping online, you don’t have direct interaction with the producer. Therefore, it is impossible to know the exact characteristics of your selected product. That’s why we recommend reading descriptions and reviews of your selected brown mustard. All the products mentioned above have a great reputation and hundreds of positive reviews. To know more about mustard, take a look at our article about honey mustard.


Most people look at the price very first before buying anything. Today, many companies make mustard, but you cannot just randomly choose one, as we discussed. A product’s quality is dependent upon its price. We have featured both cheap and expensive high-quality mustards in our list, so it’s easy for you to choose a pocket-friendly product.

Stick to your budget because the last thing you want is to buy mustard for a sandwich that will leave you broke. Commonly, mustard is not that expensive. For example, a 20-oz bottle of high-quality mustard should not cost more than $30. But if your trusted producer is providing healthy mustard made from premium ingredients, you should consider spending some extra bucks.