If you love to bake, you must have tried to make a jelly roll once or twice. While other pans might produce undercooked or undersized sponge cakes, the best jelly roll pans never disappoint. They are designed to give you the right size, texture, and appetizing appearance.
A jelly roll is a tasty dessert created when jelly is spread on a sponge cake and rolled into a cylinder-like shape. Essentially, this pan is a baking sheet with 1-inch rim sides used in baking this delicious dessert. Jelly roll pans look like half sheets, but they are narrower. While you might be tempted to bake a jelly roll with other kinds of pans, none of them can do the job better than the best jelly roll pans.
This is one essential pan to have in your cabinet if you plan to treat your family to some of the best jelly rolls once in a while. To get high-quality pans should not be a problem because we have done most of the work for you. Below are our five (5) best jelly roll pans.
Best Jelly Roll Pans
|Image||Best Jelly Roll Pans||Rating|
|1. USA Pan Jelly Roll Pan||99%|
|2. Nordic Ware Naturals Jelly Roll Pan||96%|
|3. Doughmakers Jelly Roll Pan||92%|
|4. OXO Jelly Roll Pan||89%|
|5. Nordic Ware Prism Aluminum Jelly Roll Pan||85%|
Want to learn more?
Here are our Best Jelly Roll Pans reviews.
We understand that you need a pan that won’t frustrate your efforts of making the best jelly rolls. The commercial-grade USA-Pan Jelly Roll Pan is what we recommend for you. It has a premium aluminized steel construction that is sure to last a long time. Fortunately, this pan does not warp at high temperatures. It is one of the best jelly roll pans for your commercial baking.
The USA-Pan Jelly Roll Pan features a surface marked with parallel ridges that guarantee proper air circulation. The items you bake on this pan will be evenly baked. Its corrugated surface allows the baked item to be released without losing shape. It is worthy to note that this pan is coated with a silicone-based Non-stick coating that is Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) free.
This heavy gauge pan features a 14.2 x 9.3 x 1-inch inner surface dimension and weighs 1.9 pounds. Its size makes it a good fit for any oven. Its reinforced steel wire rim adds to the strength that makes it resistant to twisting and bending. Apart from jelly rolls, the USA-Pan Jelly Roll Pan allows you to roast vegetables, bake cookies and make delicious french-fries. We recommend you hand wash this pan with hot water, soap, and a sponge.
Why do we like it?
- Lifetime warranty
- Bisphenol-A (BPA) free
- Highly durable
If you are bent on delivering tasty and nutritious jelly rolls for your family consumption, the Nordic Ware Naturals Jelly Roll Pan is the pan you need. This exceptional aluminum jelly roll pan has top-notch heat conductivity. We rate it highly because it allows you to bake multiple rolls in lesser time. Your batter is sure to rise and bake evenly without burning. More so, its non-stick surface means that you won’t be losing any of your delicious jelly rolls to the pan.
Nordic measures 15.25 x 10.76 x 1.13-inches and weighs just 1.35 pounds. It also features a rigid galvanized steel rim that prevents the pan from warping. We also like its durability because it can withstand extremely hot temperatures. The Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan’s interior golden finish is resistant to scratch and ugly marks.
Be it a Thanksgiving Day or a big family dinner night; this reliable jelly roll pan will not disappoint you. It puts you in control of the baking process while removing the stress involved. You can roast ribs, chicken, and seafood at as high as 400 degrees without breaking a sweat. Its outstanding performance makes it one of the best jelly roll pans available on the market.
Why do we like it?
- Very versatile
- Easy to clean and store
- Serves as a nice gift
Perhaps you are tired of adding oils, sprays, and shortenings to your old pan before baking. The Doughmakers Jelly Roll Pan is the best pan you can get as a substitute. It features a Pebble Pattern surface that is naturally non-stick and therefore doesn’t need any shortenings. It has a grade 18 gauge aluminum construction that guarantees unbeatable performance. If you bake commercially, this is the jelly roll pan you need.
The Doughmakers Jelly Roll Pan measures 15 x 10 x 0.75-inches and weighs 1 pound. It makes baking cookies and roasting vegetables easy and fun. You will be glad to know that this pan allows maximum airflow under your baked items, which allows for perfect browning and even baking. You can bake your rolls in less time due to its high-heat retention and transfer.
Doughmakers is more rust-proof and corrosion-resistant than most aluminized steel pans. Feel free to use a knife on this jelly roll pan. Scratches from knives do not affect its outstanding performance. When cleaning this pan, make sure you avoid using chlorine-based detergents that degrade its effectiveness. We recommend it to homeowners and professional bakers.
Why do we like it?
- Strengthened handle areas
- Highly reliable
- Releases baked food easily
It is essential to get a jelly roll pan that can last long and perform optimally. The Oxo Jelly Roll Pan, with its heavy-gauge aluminized steel construction, is a must-have. This 10 x 15 x 1-inch pan features a 2-layered ceramic reinforced polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) coating that is non-stick and high quality. Its surface allows optimal airflow that delivers even baking while reducing surface contact. This pan easily releases the baked item due to its micro-textured pattern surface.
Oxo jelly roll pan comes in a square shape that for easy carriage even while hot. It also offers a good grip that prevents the jelly roll pan from slipping out of your hand and ruining your delicacies. Due to its quality build, the Oxo jelly roll pan assures you of even heat distribution across its surface.
Weighing only 1.56 pounds, you can load it up with batter without worrying about how heavy it’ll become. If you want a reliable jelly roll pan that would last, this is the pan for you. It is rust-proof and corrosion-resistant. It is also very easy to clean with soap and water.
Why do we like it?
- Very sturdy
- Excellent for commercial use
- Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) free
There is hardly any other jelly roll pan that offers you efficiency, like the Nordic Ware Prism Aluminum Jelly Roll Pan. This functional pan possesses a heat dispersion ability that we rate as one of the best. The fast heating is largely due to the massive heat conductivity of its super-hardened aluminum alloy build. We included this pan in our list because it guarantees you evenly baked rolls that will slide off the pan with ease. Scouring pads and knives might scratch this jelly roll pan, but it doesn’t affect its performance in any way.
Its internal surface showcases a shiny natural uncoated aluminum material that is non-stick. High temperature does no harm to this pan. What Nordic Prism offers you is a pan of consistent results every time you use it. Nordic Ware Prism Aluminum Jelly Roll Pan works well with silicone baking mats and parchment paper. We recommend using silicone or wood utensils with this pan if you want it to last long.
Might we also add that the prism grid pattern on this pan improves airflow and makes the pan highly durable. The surface is also wide at 15.1 x 10.6 x 1-inch. It also weighs 1.3 pounds only. We highly encourage you to avoid using vinegar and acidic tomato products on the surface as they weaken the surface.
Why do we like it?
- Has encapsulated steel rims to prevent warping
- It is non-porous
- Rust resistant
Jelly Roll Pans Buyer’s Guide
So many jelly roll pans are up for sale in stores. So, therefore, picking the right one can be a bit tricky. If you are a beginner with little or no experience, the chances are that you will make the wrong choice. To save your time and resources, we have compiled a buyer’s guide for you. Please read our guide to know the most important things to consider when shopping for the best jelly roll pans.
Jelly pans are made with different materials, such as aluminized steel, stainless steel, aluminum, or Silicone. You should pay attention to the heat distribution capabilities of each of them before buying. Aluminum pans conduct heat faster than the rest and also distribute it better. They are also naturally non-stick. Pans made with aluminum are also scratch-resistant and don’t easily warp. We further recommend aluminum because the material is dishwasher safe.
Buying a jelly roll pan that is easy to clean is crucial. Non-stick surfaces won’t give you much stress. This why the build material of the pan is important. We further recommend that you buy the best pans that are dishwasher safe.
Texture of surface
If the pan has a wavy surface and textured grid ridges, it means that your jelly rolls will be exposed to airflow during the baking session. Smooth surface pans might not have this capability, so avoid them if you want the best result. Consider going for the best Jelly roll pans with textured surfaces that do not warp very easily.