5 Best Horseradish Mustards (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

If you love spicy meals, horseradish mustard is a must-have condiment for you. This condiment gives your dull food a mouth-watering flavor. It is a combination of cider vinegar, mustard seed, minced garlic, white horseradish, salt, and light-brown sugar. This mustard is so diverse because not every brand uses different ingredients and formulas.

Due to a lot of variations, selecting a product that will suit you best is quite a pickle. To get the best quality horseradish mustard, you must do some research and invest your time. But you don’t have to worry; to save your precious time, we have compiled a list of some of the best Horseradish mustard that customers can get their hands on.

Best Horseradish Mustards

Want to learn more?

Here are our Horseradish Mustard reviews.

1. Weber’s Brand Horseradish Mustard

Weber's Brand Horseradish Mustard

When it comes to hot yet delicious horseradish mustard, no other product can beat Weber’s Brand Horseradish Mustard. This mustard is available in different sizes and flavors, including jalapeno, piccalilli, Texan sauce, and many more. A 16-ounce bottle of this delicious condiment only costs about $11, which is quite inexpensive and worth every penny.

Weber’s Brand Horseradish Mustard comprises premium ingredients including horseradish, mustard seed, soybean oil, xanthan gum, vinegar, ascorbic acid, salt, and paprika. This product is probably the most reviewed item available in the market, so it’s not just one individual who likes it. In addition, this condiment is quite healthy; it is gluten-free, fat-free, and does not have any carbs.

Why do we like it? 

  • Hot and Spicy Condiment
  • Organic Ingredients
  • Durable Packaging
  • Free from Fat and Gluten
Check Price on Amazon


2. Annie’s Horseradish Mustard

Annie's Horseradish Mustard

The second condiment on our list is Annie’s Horseradish Mustard. Being second does not mean this product is not worth buying; in fact, this horseradish mustard is even more inexpensive and delicious than the above one. A 9-ounce bottle of this mouth-watering condiment can cost up to $5, making it the most inexpensive item on our list.

Annie’s Horseradish Mustard is certified organic. This condiment is made of the best quality ingredients, including organic horseradish, mustard seed, paprika, sea salt, and apple cider vinegar. Its non-GMO ingredients provide a perfect amount of zing to praise any meal. In addition, this product is pure and does not contain added preservatives, colors, or artificial flavors.

Why do we like it? 

  • Gluten-Free
  • Low in Sodium
  • Durable Beer Mug
  • Premium Ingredients
Check Price on Amazon


3. Plochman’s Spicy Horseradish Mustard

Plochman's Spicy Horseradish Mustard

Another condiment that deserves a spot on our list is Plochman’s Spicy 11 Ounce Horseradish Mustard. This item is available in different flavors and sizes. It is made of all-natural ingredients and gives an extra special kick to your meals. A pack of two 11-ounce bottles of this delicious horseradish mustard can cost up to $18, which is quite economical.

Plochman’s Spicy 11 Ounce Horseradish Mustard is made of horseradish, soybean oil, salt, water, distilled vinegar, citric acid, mustard seed, spices, and more. This product is non-GMO, gluten-free, and contains potassium sorbate as a preservative. A mixture of this condiment with brown mustard gives an extra zing of excitement to dishes like pork, beef, vegetable dip, sausage, and beyond.

Why do we like it? 

  • Extra Hot and Spicy
  • Versatile Condiment
  • Premium Ingredients
  • Durable Packaging
Check Price on Amazon


4. Emeril’s Mustard Horseradish

Emeril's Mustard Horseradish

Next, we have Emeril’s Mustard Horseradish. If you have used Emeril’s German mustard or other condiments, you sure know that they are delicious and quite affordable. Emeril’s Mustard Horseradish is made from premium ingredients, including ground red paprika, horseradish powder, salt, mustard seed, water, and distilled vinegar.

Emeril’s Mustard Horseradish is quite affordable; a twelve-ounce durable bottle of this delicious condiment only costs up to $7. This mustard tastes better compared to Dijon mustard. It is not too hot nor too sweet; this condiment provides a perfect amount of heat without overpowering your meal. This product is nothing if not versatile; you can use it on pork, sausages, ribs, beef, and many more.

Why do we like it? 

  • Made in the USA
  • Mouth-Watering Flavor
  • Affordable Condiment
  • Fresh Ingredients
Check Price on Amazon


5. Braswells Hot Horseradish Mustard

Braswells Hot Horseradish Mustard

Lastly, we have Braswells Hot Horseradish Mustard. Unlike other horseradish mustard on our list, this one comes in a jar that looks elegant in every kitchen. This product is quite healthy; it is free from cholesterol, saturated fat, carb, trans fat, and sugar. In addition, this condiment is made with all-natural and fresh ingredients and only costs up to $14.

Braswells Hot Horseradish Mustard is made with mustard oil, spices, white wine, kosher salt, mustard seed, horseradish, citric acid, and distilled white vinegar. This mustard is spicy and flavorful; you can use this condiment on any food, including turkey, hamburger, ham, pork, beef, and many more. Once the mustard is used up, you can use its jar as an excellent juice glass.

Why do we like it? 

  • Durable Jar
  • Fresh and Tasty
  • All-Natural Ingredients
  • No Added Preservatives
Check Price on Amazon


Horseradish Mustard Buyer’s Guide

Mustard is the most commonly used condiment all around the globe. This condiment is available in different variations such as German mustardhoney mustard, and of course, horseradish mustard. When it comes to healthy yet spicy mustard, no other condiment can beat this mustard. However, there are some things you must consider for getting high-quality horseradish mustard. This buyer’s guide will help you understand different areas to help you choose the horseradish mustard that best serves your needs.


Suppose you are buying a product on the internet. In that case, it is impossible for you to interact with the producer directly, which makes it quite hard to know the exact specifications and characteristics of your selected horseradish mustard. Therefore, we suggest reading reviews and descriptions of a product before investing your money. All the products as mentioned earlier are highly positively reviewed and have a great reputation.


The quality and shelf life of your selected horseradish mustard will be determined by its ingredients. While buying online, make sure your selected product is made with all-natural and fresh ingredients. In addition, the ingredients of your horseradish mustard must be non-GMO. Furthermore, ideal horseradish mustard does not contain added preservatives, colors, or artificial flavors. To know more about horseradish, take a look at our article about Horseradish: Everything You Need To Know.

Nutritional Facts

Health is Wealth. While shopping online, don’t forget to read the nutritional fact table. For example, healthy horseradish mustard contains a low amount of cholesterol, sugar, saturated fat, calories, and carbs. An ideal bottle of horseradish mustard contains less than ten calories per serving and zero grams of saturated fat.

And if you follow a gluten-free and keto diet, make sure your selected condiment is keto and gluten-free. In addition, your selected mustard must be kosher certified and must not contain fillers or MSG. Of course, if you think horseradish is too hot for you, you can always buy a Dijon Mustard for your hot dogs and sandwiches.


While exploring the internet for delicious condiments, budget is an important factor to pinpoint. Always stick with your budget; you don’t want to spend your whole month’s budget on a bottle of horseradish mustard. If you have a hungry family, buy an economical pack of your favorite mustard; otherwise, stick with an individual bottle.

An ideal 15-ounce bottle of horseradish mustard should not cost more than $15. But if your selected brand is selling all-natural and delicious mustard, spending some extra bucks is worth considering. Finally, if you love hot dogs, check out our top 5 mustards for hot dogs.