Best Honey Mustard

5 Best Honey Mustards (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.
Honey mustard is quite a popular condiment around; this mustard adds a bit of sweetness to your savory dishes. There is no denying that honey mustard is a must-have condiment for your kitchen. Because of its tangy and sweet flavor, this versatile staple can be used for many dishes, from sandwich and salad dressing to more complicated meals.

Now the real question is, which honey mustard will be perfect for you? Because various brands are producing this kitchen staple, selecting the best product is quite a challenge. Therefore, it would be best for you to do some research before investing your money in high-quality honey mustard. To save your precious time, below, we have provided a list of the top 5 best honey mustards that customers can get their hands on.

Best Honey Mustards

Want to learn more?

Here are our honey mustard reviews.

1. Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard

Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard

On top of our list, we have Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard. It is one of the most positively reviewed honey mustards available out there, so it’s not just one person who likes it. This condiment is healthy, delicious, and incredibly tasty. Regardless of its high quality, this kitchen staple is quite affordable; a thirteen ounces bottle of this honey mustard only costs about $8.

Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard is made of premium ingredients, including honey, sugar, wheat flour, water, distilled vinegar, mustard seed, soybean oil, and many more. Thanks to its sweet honey flavor, you can use this condiment on a sandwich, chicken nuggets, pretzels, hot dog, burger, and beyond. Furthermore, its squeezable bottle comes with travel-friendly flip cans.

Why do we like it? 

  • Healthy Dips
  • Premium Ingredients
  • Flavorful Condiments
  • Sweet Honey Flavor
Check Price on Amazon


2. Heinz Honey Mustard

Heinz Honey Mustard

Another great condiment that deserves a spot on our list is Heinz Honey Mustard. This honey mustard is made with premium and fresh ingredients, including white distilled vinegar, mustard seed, cane sugar, salt, honey, brown sugar, and turmeric. A pack of six fifteen ounces bottles of this product only costs about $15, which is surprisingly inexpensive.

Heinz Honey Mustard is not too hot nor too sweet; you will fall in love with its rich flavor with a hint of sweetness. To experience its full flavor, try using this honey mustard as a dipping sauce, or put it on hot dogs, sandwiches, burgers, and beyond. This product is healthy and kosher certified. In addition, its squeezable bottle is easy-to-use, convenient, and BPA-free.

Why do we like it? 

  • Premium Ingredient with Real Honey
  • Rich Taste
  • Squeezable Bottle
  • Kosher Certified
Check Price on Amazon


3. Inglehoffer Honey Mustard

Inglehoffer Honey Mustard

Next, we have Inglehoffer Honey Mustard. If you have consumed other Inglehoffer condiments, you surely know that these products are quite affordable and delicious. This honey mustard is not that expensive, and a pack of two 10.25-ounce bottles only costs up to $11. This condiment is nothing if not versatile; you can use this honey mustard on many items, including chicken, burger, hot dogs, and more.

Inglehoffer Honey Mustard is made of fresh ingredients, including honey, sugar, wheat flour, water, distilled vinegar, mustard seed, soybean oil, and many more. This product provides your meals a tangy and sweet taste that goes perfect with everything. If you are looking for a condiment that delivers an enjoyable and familiar experience yet breaks the mold, then Inglehoffer Honey Mustard is a perfect pick for you.

Why do we like it? 

  • Affordable Pack of Two
  • Durable Packaging
  • Mouth-Watering Flavor
  • Premium Ingredients
Check Price on Amazon


4. French’s Honey Mustard

French's Honey Mustard

This all-around honey mustard is probably the healthiest condiment available out there. This one is vegetarian, gluten-free, cholesterol-free, dairy-free, and free from peanuts, fat, soybeans, and tree nuts. French’s Honey Mustard is made of fresh ingredients, including mustard seed, distilled vinegar, carrot oleoresin, salt, honey, sugar, and water.

French’s Honey Mustard is not that expensive; a 105-ounce bottle of this mustard can cost up to $14. This product is made of entire mustard seed and delivers the perfect balance of tangy and sweet flavor. In addition, this condiment is quite versatile; you can use the pump option for topping applications to add on burgers, hot dogs, pretzels, sandwiches, sides, and many more.

Why do we like it? 

  • Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free
  • Perfectly Balanced
  • Premium Ingredients
  • Free from Fat and Cholesterol
Check Price on Amazon


5. Emeril’s Smooth Honey Mustard

Emeril's Smooth Honey Mustard

Finally, we have Emeril’s Smooth Honey Mustard. This one is available in different sizes and packs. A twelve ounces bottle of this delicious honey mustard is quite economical and costs about $7. It is made with all-natural ingredients, including brown sugar, salt, cider vinegar, sugar, smooth honey, mustard seed, water, distilled vinegar, and many more.

Emeril’s Smooth Honey Mustard adds something extra to your savory dishes while still retaining that original flavor. This product comes in a BPA-free squeezable bottle with a length of fifteen centimeters. To increase its shelf life, we recommend refrigerating this honey mustard after opening the bottle. According to one consumer, this one is great for cooking and can be used for sandwiches, hot dogs, and burgers.

Why do we like it? 

  • All-Natural Ingredients
  • Real Smooth Honey
  • Delicious Taste
  • Healthy Condiment
Check Price on Amazon


Honey Mustard Buyer’s Guide

It’s hard to say that all honey mustard brands use the same ingredients and formula to make delicious and high-quality products. Because this condiment is a mixture of mustard seed and honey, most brands may use the same principle, but the difference in processes and qualities make one staple better than others. To help you out, here is a complete guide for you to keep in mind while selecting the best quality honey mustard.

Origin and Type of Honey

Does Honey Mustard Go Bad? We all have asked this question in our life at least one time. Well, the answer to this question depends upon the type and origin of honey. Most people think that all honey tastes the same. But many professional chefs believe that the origin of particular honey has a deep effect on its flavor and taste.

Furthermore, it would be best for you to read the description and labeling while selecting honey mustard. Because many reputable brands even identify the flower source and the type of honey they used to make honey mustard. Make sure your selected honey mustard is made with fresh and real honey.

Mustard Seed

The second most important ingredient of honey mustard is the mustard seed. Three types of mustard seeds are available out there; black, brown, and white. Black seeds have the most intense taste, while white ones are the mildest of the bunch. When it comes to brown mustards, also known as Indian mustard, they fall somewhere in the middle. It would be best for you to remember the variations of mustard seed because they affect the end result of your selected product.

Other Ingredient

Your store-bought honey mustard is not just a mixture of honey and mustard. This condiment also contains some other ingredients like sugar, salt, vinegar, and more. You should make sure that these additional ingredients are natural and fresh. In addition, your selected honey mustard must be gluten-free, dairy-free, and free of cholesterol and fat. To know more about mustard, don’t forget to read our article about Brown Mustard: Everything You Need To Know.


When it comes to kitchen staples, we always recommend staying within your budget. Because the last thing you want is to buy a condiment that will leave you broke. Honey mustard is not that expensive. A 15-ounces of honey mustard should not cost more than $20. However, if your trusted producer is providing a high-quality product with all-natural ingredients, spending some extra bucks is worth considering. If you are a BBQ lover, check out our top articles about Honey BBQ Sauce and Mustard BBQ Sauce.