Best Carolina Bbq Sauce

5 Best Carolina BBQ Sauces (Reviews Updated 2021)

A BBQ lover surely knows that not all barbeque sauces are the same. Some dishes require sweet flavor, while others need a tangy barbeque sauce. If you want a tangy and thick flavor with a very subtle sweetness, you are going to love Carolina BBQ sauce. While southwest style contains a good amount of sugar, the Carolina BBQ sauces have a very little amount of sugar, resulting in a tangier and sour flavor.

Because different companies are manufacturing this delicious barbeque sauce, finding a product that will suit you best is quite a challenge. But you don’t have to worry; below, we have given a list of the best Carolina BBQ sauces that you can get your hands on.

Best Carolina BBQ Sauces

Want to learn more?

Here are our Carolina BBQ Sauce reviews.

1. Cattlemen’s Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ Sauce

Cattlemen's Carolina Tangy Gold Bbq Sauce

If you are looking for a tangy and mouth-watering Carolina barbeque sauce, Cattlemen’s Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ Sauce is the perfect choice for you. This Carolina barbeque sauce is probably the most positively reviewed item on our list, so it’s not just one person that likes it. However, this one is quite affordable, and a pack of 2 18-oz bottles can cost up to $12.

Cattlemen’s Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ Sauce comes with dimensions of 7 x 6.5 x 2 inches and weighs about 2.54 pounds. This sauce is made with mustard seed, aged cayenne, molasses, and hickory smoke. You can enjoy this sauce as wing glaze, salad dressing, or dip. It is kosher certified and does not contain fillers, high-fructose corn syrup, and starches.

Why do we like it?  

  • No High-Fructose Corn Syrup
  • Sweet and Savory Taste
  • Kosher Certified
  • Versatile Sauce with Multiple Use
Check Price on Amazon

 

2. Heinz Carolina Mustard Style BBQ Sauce

Heinz Carolina Mustard Style Bbq Sauce

Second, on our list is Heinz Carolina Mustard Style BBQ Sauce. You can buy Heinz sauce with mustard flavor or BBQ and Vinegar one. The mustard-style barbeque sauce is quite affordable, and a pack of 6 costs about $12. This award-winning BBQ sauce is completely gluten-free. This product comes with dimensions of ‎ 10.81 x 4.81 x 7.5 inches and 7.86 pounds.

Heinz Carolina Mustard Style BBQ Sauce is made with blackstrap molasses, yellow mustard, and cane sugar that provides a spicy and tangy flavor with a one-of-a-kind sweet taste. Its mouth-watering flavor is perfect for pork, chicken, and ribs, either as a table sauce or use this barbeque sauce as a BBQ marinade. Furthermore, you can use this delicious barbeque sauce as an ingredient for your homemade sauce.

Why do we like it?  

  • Inexpensive
  • Durable Packaging
  • Maximum Flavor
  • Delicious Glaze
Check Price on Amazon

 

3. Lillie’s Q Carolina Barbeque Sauce

Lillie's Q Carolina Barbeque Sauce

No barbecue sauce list can be completed without Lillie’s Q sauces. If you have used other Lillie’s Q barbeque sauces recently, you surely know that they are high-quality and quite durable. In addition, this sauce is quite affordable; a 20-ounce Lillie’s Q Carolina BBQ sauce can cost up to $24 and is worth every single penny.

Lillie’s Q – Carolina Barbeque Sauce comes with dimensions of ‎ 2.75 x 2.75 x 6.6 inches and weighs about 3.66 pounds. This sauce is made with all-natural and gluten-free ingredients that mean no preservatives, no high-fructose corn syrup, and no MSG. This BBQ sauce is perfect for hot dogs, burgers, pulled pork, wings, smoked chicken, steak, fries, and many more.

Why do we like it?  

  • Western Traditional Carolina Sauce
  • No preservatives and MSG
  • Durable Packaging
  • Gluten-Free
Check Price on Amazon

 

4. Cattlemen’s Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ Sauce

Cattlemen's Carolina Tangy Gold Bbq Sauce

If you are a BBQ lover or going to use a lot of barbeque sauce, then this one is perfect for you. Cattlemen’s Carolina sauce comes in a one-gallon container and costs about $18. This sauce is quite versatile and offers superior performance; you can use this sauce as BBQ sauce or a colorful glaze for wings, salmon, chicken, shrimp, and many more.

Cattlemen’s Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ Sauce has dimensions of 15.5 x 11.5 x 6.5 inches and weighs about 10 pounds. This sauce is a mixture of sweet molasses, creamy mustard, sugar, zesty that provides a robust flavor. In addition, this Carolina BBQ sauce is vegetarian, kosher, and free from eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, and fish. This barbeque sauce is made with all-natural and gluten-free ingredients and doesn’t contain high-fructose syrup, fillers, or starches.

Why do we like it?  

  • One gal Container
  • Robust Flavor
  • Versatile Sauce
  • Kosher Certified
Check Price on Amazon

 

5. Lillie’s Q Barbeque Sauce Variety Pack

Lillie's Q Barbeque Sauce Variety Pack

Last but not least, we have another Lillie’s Q product. If you liked the above-mentioned Lillie’s Q Carolina sauce but want to invest some more bucks to buy a variety pack, then this one is for you. Other than Carolina barbeque sauce, this variety pack contains gold barbeque sauce and smoky barbeque sauce. This pack of 3 Lillie’s Q BBQ sauces can cost up to $27.

The packaging of Lillie’s Q – Barbeque Sauce Variety Pack comes with dimensions of 9.13 x 7.36 x 6.46 inches and weighs about 3 Ounces. This BBQ sauce is perfect for hot dogs, burgers, pulled pork, wings, smoked chicken, steak, fries, and many more. It is made with all-natural and gluten-free ingredients that mean no preservatives, no high-fructose corn syrup, and no MSG.

Why do we like it?  

  • Authentically Crafted BBQ
  • Gluten-Free and All-Ingredients
  • Sweet and Tangy
  • Versatile Sauces
Check Price on Amazon

 

Carolina BBQ Sauce Buyer’s Guide

You can easily buy a BBQ sauce for pulled pork or BBQ sauce of Ribs, but selecting a high-quality Carolina BBQ sauce is not an easy task. There are some things you should consider before investing your money and time into a high-quality Carolina BBQ sauce. To help you out, we have mentioned below some important factors to keep in mind while buying a Carolina BBQ sauce that will suit you best.

Ingredients

Ingredients used in a Carolina BBQ sauce are the most important things to pinpoint. Different ingredients provide different tastes. Commonly, the Carolina sauce is made with mustard, tomatoes, pepper, and vinegar. Make sure your selected gluten-free BBQ sauce is made with all-natural ingredients and has no MSG or Preservatives. If your Carolina sauce has a little amount of sugar in it, the flavor would be mild and tangy with a subtle touch of sweetness.

Budget

While buying food products, the budget is probably the most important factor to consider. The last thing you need is to buy a Carolina BBQ sauce that will leave you broke. The above-mentioned Carolina sauces are quite affordable and don’t cost much. in our experience, if you have a limited budget, popular BBQ Sauce brands make healthier and more inexpensive sauces compared to the local ones.

Shelf Life

An off-smelling Carolina barbeque sauce can make any event an unfortunate experience. Furthermore, an expired Carolina barbeque sauce is quite harmful to your health. Therefore, try to buy a Carolina BBQ sauce that has a great shelf life. To play it safe, before using a Carolina sauce, make sure it is fresh. Most of the Carolina sauces have a shelf life of more than one year. But we won’t recommend using a sauce for more than three months.

Salt and Sugar

You should be careful about the calories and sugar intake in your everyday meals. Therefore, before selecting a Carolina BBQ sauce, read all the nutrition facts and ingredients carefully. Normally, 500 milligrams of sodium per serving is ideal to some extent. If you are a BBQ lover, check out our top 5 BBQ Temperature Controllers and best Gas BBQ Grills.