5 Best Canned Pumpkin (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.
Pumpkin powder is one ingredient that has different uses. Some people use it as a texture firmer, to improve the flavor of food or consumed whole. Its taste is one of the reasons why it has become a popular food source. However, the fresh version has a short lifecycle that is why the best canned pumpkin is widely used in place of fresh pumpkin. You can use it for your baking or improve the taste of your pastries or sauce. What’s more? You can even use it as a source of vegetables for your baby.

With so many uses, canned pumpkin is one ingredient that should never run out of supply in your home. With that being said, you need to shop for the best brands if you want pumpkins that offer value for money. With so many brands out there, we understand that it can be a little tricky to pick a good brand for your home. To help you out, we have done the selection for you. Here are some of the best canned pumpkin products there are.

Best Canned Pumpkin

Want to learn more?

Here are our Best Canned Pumpkin Reviews.

1. Libby’s Pure Organic Pumpkin

Libby’s Pure Organic Pumpkin

Libby’s Pure Organic Pumpkin is made of 100% pure organic pumpkin and certified as natural and gluten-free. While many other products may contain gluten and other unnatural agents, this best canned pumpkin product is wholly organic. The quality you pay for is the quality you get with this product. You can use it for baking your pies and other kinds of pastries. You can also use it to improve the flavor of your food.

Libby’s is one of the best canned pumpkin products you can buy for your cooking and baking. It is a good source of fiber and low in fat. If you are looking to cut down on your cholesterol, this is a very good addition to your menu.

We recommend that you use Libby’s in food under low heat, so you get the full value of its nutritious properties.

Why do we like it?

  • Abundant quantity
  • Non-GMO
  • Ideal for various recipes
Check Price on Amazon


2. Farmer’s Market Foods Canned Pumpkin

Farmer’s Market Foods Canned Pumpkin

Farmer’s Market Organic Pumpkin is another nutrient-rich pumpkin that will add value to your family’s recipe. This product can be used for several recipes, too numerous to mention in this review. However, what makes it a top draw for buyers are two key factors. Firstly, it is very affordable, so families with a small budget can stock their homes. Secondly, the pumpkin loaded into the can is organic and devoid of unnatural properties.

Farmer’s Market Foods come in a pack of 12, and each pack contains 15 ounces of pumpkin. In terms of quality, this product is one you will not regret having in your home. You can use it for your pastry recipes, oatmeals, hot drinks, and smoothies. You can even add it to your child’s menu, and he will love you for it.

This Pumpkin puree is made with whole pumpkins and can last for three days once opened. However, avoid keeping it in a refrigerator.

Why do we like it?

  • Organic certified product
  • Ideal for multiple uses
  • A great source of beta-carotene
Check Price on Amazon


3. Amazon Brand Happy Belly Organic Pumpkin

Amazon Brand Happy Belly Organic Pumpkin

When making our selection, we ensured that all the brands we picked our organic are certified by various reputed institutes and agencies. This Happy Belly Organic pumpkin by Amazon Basics is a USDA-certified pumpkin. Happy Belly is certified and completely kosher. This makes it an ideal selection for kosher diets.

This best canned pumpkin is also ideal for vegans who want to avoid animal fat and non-plant foods as much as possible. The flavor of Happy Belly is 100% natural and devoid of sugar. Each 15 ounce can contains only pumpkin and nothing else.

The pumpkin in this can is grown in the US and non-GMO. For best value, make sure you consume it 3 days after you open it.

Why do we like it?

  • Value for money
  • Very affordable
  • Low carbs
Check Price on Amazon


4. Libby’s Pumpkin Pie Filling

Libby’s Pumpkin Pie Filling

This is another product from the stable of Libby’s for pie fillings. If you love to add pumpkin flavors to your pies and pastries, this is one of the best canned pumpkin you can use. The contents in this can serves different purposes, and you are not restricted to the recipes you can use it for. However, when you use it for baking pies, we guarantee you the best results possible.

Your pies will not only have firm textures, but their taste will also be worth the experience. Some of the other recipes you can use Libyy’s for include bread, cookies, muffins, pancakes, and even your soup if you want it to have a thick texture.

Each 16 LB can has 10oz worth of pumpkins, which is enough to bake as many pies as you want or prepare other recipes.

Why do we like it?

  • Flavor enhancer
  • Solid packaging
  • It does not contain allergens
Check Price on Amazon


5. Gerber 2nd Foods Pumpkin

Gerber 2nd Foods Pumpkin

Gerber 2nd Foods Pumpkin baby food is a product with a tried and tested quality. It comes in a pack of two, and each pack contains 8-ounce worth of pumpkin. This product has various uses, and one of them is that it can serve as baby food. If you decide to buy Gerber for your baby, rest assured that your child will get a product that contains healthy nutrients and is safe. In addition, all the ingredients in this can ate fresh fruits and vegetables of the highest standards.

With 1/3 cup of pumpkin in each tub, you have more than enough to keep your baby well fed. In addition, all the pumpkins in Gerber were grown under clean farming practices, and they are devoid of GMO or unnatural properties.

This pumpkin can should be kept in a cool, dry place away from light.

Why do we like it?

  • Quality packaging
  • Unsweetened and unsalted recipe
  • Healthy and free of artificial flavors and colorings
Check Price on Amazon


Canned Pumpkin Buyer’s Guide

If you understand why pumpkin goes bad, you may see the value of getting nothing but the best canned pumpkin for your recipes. Shopping for canned pumpkin is similar to shopping for low carb bbq sauces or waffle mixes. Keeping your eyes on certain ingredient information and product features is the only way you will get the value you seek. With so many pumpkin brands floating around, this is essential. So, without further ado, here are some of the things to keep your eyes on when evaluating the value of a product.


The first thing you should pay attention to when shopping for the best canned pumpkin is to focus on the label. The label contains all the vital information regarding the ingredients. First, you want to make sure that the pumpkin is actually pumpkin and not a squash. Squash pumpkin is merely washed or cut pumpkin that has been reduced to a pulp. This is not what you should buy. The one you should buy should be firm, properly flashed, and cultured in the can.


Not every canned pumpkin brand contains organic pumpkin, so you want to be careful. Cans that contain gluten or industrial sugar should be avoided at all cost. You also want to avoid GMO-based pumpkins. This is why we recommend that you only buy brands that have a bold and certified organic label.


What you intend to use the pumpkin for should determine the type you go for. Some of the best canned pumpkin are ideal for baking, while others are best for cooking. Make the distinction between the two by reverting to the product label or reading customer reviews. If you want to improve the flavor of bbq potato chips or baked chips a little more, make sure the one you go for is best suited for baking.