Best Canned Marinara Sauce

5 Best Canned Marinara Sauce (Reviews Updated 2021)

Canned Marinara Sauce is a must-have pantry staple for every homeowner. This sauce is a mixture of tomato, garlic, olive oil, onion, and basil. From creating a delicious base of a rich stew to whipping up a mouth-watering weeknight dinner, canned marinara sauces are essential and versatile ingredients for your pantry.

Now the real question is, which canned marinara sauce will be perfect for your pantry? Because different brands are selling this tasty sauce, selecting a single sauce is quite challenging. But you don’t have to fret; to help you out, we have mentioned some of the best canned marinara sauces you can buy without spending your whole month’s budget.

Best Canned Marinara Sauces

Want to learn more?

Here are our Canned Marinara Sauce reviews.

1. Yo Mama’s Foods Marinara Sauce

Yo Mama's Foods Marinara Sauce

If you are looking for a mouth-watering and fresh, canned marinara sauce, Yo Mama’s Foods Marinara Sauce is the best pick for you. This sauce is available in different sizes and flavors; you can either buy a normal marinara sauce or a spicy marinara sauce. In addition, this one is one of the most reviewed products available out there, so it’s not just one person who likes it.

Yo Mama’s Foods Marinara Sauce is quite affordable; a pack of 2, 1.56-pound cans only costs about $16. Its packaging has dimensions of ‎7.32 x 7.17 x 7.09 inches and weighs about 5.05 pounds. In addition, this marinara sauce is quite healthy; it is completely gluten-free, preservatives-free, low-sodium, Low-Glycemic, Paleo-Friendly, and non-GMO.

Why do we like it?  

  • Fits Every Occasion
  • Premium Quality Ingredients
  • Healthy Marina Sauce
  • Compatible with Keto Life-Style
Check Price on Amazon


2. Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce

Rao's Homemade Marinara Sauce

The second item on our list is Rao’s Homemade 28 Oz Marinara Sauce. This sauce is available in different sizes. A pack of 2 28-oz cans is quite affordable and can cost up to $20. It is made with all-natural and premium ingredients, including Italian plum tomatoes. With a weight of 5.34 pounds, this sauce has dimensions of 7.72 x 6.97 x 3.54 inches.

Rao’s Homemade 28 Oz Marinara Sauce is made with wholesome and high-quality ingredients, including olive oil, tomatoes, basil, onions, oregano, and garlic. This sauce contains no paste or added sugar, making it perfect for keto-friendly spaghetti and pasta. Besides pasta and spaghetti, you can also use this sauce as an ingredient to your delicious recipes.

Why do we like it?  

  • Premium and All-Natural Ingredients
  • Durable Packaging
  • No Added Sugar or Paste
  • Maximum Flavor
Check Price on Amazon


3. Hoboken Farms Marinara Sauce

Hoboken Farms Marinara Sauce

You cannot complete a pantry staple list without at least one Hoboken Farm product. If you have used other Hoboken sauces in the past, you know that they are quite delicious and healthy. In addition, you can buy this product in different sizes. A pack of 2 1.56 pounds’ cans is quite economical and only costs about $18, which is shockingly inexpensive.

Hoboken Farms Marinara Sauce comes with dimensions of ‎ 4 x 4 x 7 inches and weighs about 5.11 pounds. This Non-GMO marinara sauce is made with fresh tomatoes, onion, olive oil, garlic, basils, and sea salt. If you are a health freak, this sauce is a great addition to your pantry; it is Paleo-Friendly, Gluten-Free, Low-Glycemic, Preservatives-Free, Keto, and Whole 30.

Why do we like it?  

  • Non-GMO Verified Sauce
  • No preservatives and Sugar
  • Durable Packaging
  • Guilt-Free Satisfaction
Check Price on Amazon


4. Emeril’s Home-Style Marinara Sauce

Emeril's Home Style Marinara Sauce

If you are a true pasta lover and use marinara sauce regularly, this one is a perfect choice for you. Emeril’s Home-Style 25 Ounce Marinara Sauce is quite delicious and economical; a pack of 6, 25-ounce cans only costs up to $28. In addition, this one is quite versatile; you can use this sauce for spaghetti, pasta, pizza, nachos, and many more.

Emeril’s Home-Style 25 Ounce Marinara Sauce weighs about 13.93 pounds and comes with dimensions of 10.75 x 7.75 x 7 inches. This sauce is made with tomato puree, diced tomato, dried garlic, spices, dried onion, olive oil, salt, and soybean oil. It has a great shelf life of 3 years, but because of its delicious taste, you will end up using this whole pack in a couple of weeks.

Why do we like it?  

  • Kosher, Gluten-Free, and MSG-Free
  • Premium Ingredients
  • Versatile Sauce
  • No Added Preservatives
Check Price on Amazon


5. Fody Foods Marinara Sauce

Fody Foods Marinara Sauce

Last but not least, we have Fody Foods Marinara Sauce. This sauce is Non-GMO, Lactose-Free, Certified Low-FODMAP, Garlic-Free, Onion-Free, and Gluten-Free. Regardless of its high nutritional values and quality, it is still quite affordable; this one only costs up to $13, making it probably the most inexpensive marinara sauce on our list.

Fody Foods Marinara Sauce weighs about 1.83 pounds and has dimensions of 27 x 27 x 42 inches. It is made with gut-friendly and all-natural ingredients. If you cannot eat garlic or onion for some reason, this one is for you; unlike other marinara sauces, this one does not contain onion and garlic but still has a mouth-watering flavor. This sauce will be a great addition to your homemade sauces and recipes.

Why do we like it?  

  • Low-FODMAP Certified
  • Gluten-Free and All-Natural Ingredients
  • Onion and Garlic Free
  • Versatile Sauces
Check Price on Amazon


Canned Marinara Sauce Buyer’s Guide

If you are a pasta lover, canned marinara sauce is a must-have pantry staple for you. Remember that marinara sauce is not only pasta sauce; you can use this product for all of your favorite dishes. Because various brands are selling this sauce, it can be quite challenging to determine which one is best for you. To save your money and time, we have mentioned some things below that you should consider before buying marinara sauce.


When it comes to canned marinara sauce, the fewer ingredients, the better. Nothing beats the taste of juicy and fresh tomatoes. Make sure your selected marinara sauce is made with whole tomato, not tomato paste. Whole tomatoes have a better texture, lower acidity, and a sweeter taste. A sauce made of tomato paste usually has sugar and unhealthy ingredients to improve its taste. In addition, it would be best for your health if your selected sauce is Non-GMO and Gluten-Free.


While shopping for food products, budget is one of the most important factors to pinpoint. You don’t want to spend your whole month’s budget on a jar of marinara sauce. Therefore, stick with your budget. A high-quality and fresh marinara sauce with a volume of 25-ounce should not cost more than $50. But if your trusted supplier is providing a healthy sauce without any added preservatives, spending some extra bucks is worth considering.

Shelf Life

A fresh marinara sauce is good for your health. This pantry staple can reduce the risk of developing cancer and is a rich source of Vitamin A & B and proteins. However, an expired marinara sauce is quite harmful to your health. Therefore, go for a marinara sauce that has a good shelf life. Most of the products mentioned above have a shelf life of more than two years, but we won’t recommend using a canned marinara sauce for more than six months.

Sugar and Fat

To make this point simple, try to buy a canned marinara sauce that is low in sugar and high in fat. A sauce that has more fat is made with olive oil rather than vegetable oil and soybeans. This type of sauce provides natural flavor. On the other hand, if your selected sauce contains sugar, it will have an unpleasant taste and texture. Therefore, before buying a canned marinara sauce, read the full description and nutrition facts carefully. To make delicious pasta, make sure to check out our top 5 pasta cookbooks and Gluten-free pastas.