5 Best BBQ Sauces for Pizza (Reviews Updated 2022)

This post contains affiliate links, and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links, at no cost to you.

Do you want a fast savory dish? Go for that round wheat-based dough with a variety of toppings popularly known as pizza. Pizza is delicious, but most importantly, you would need the best BBQ sauce for pizza if you really want to enjoy it to the last bite. The best BBQ sauces that go well with pizza usually have a sweet, tangy flavor and can be spicy. Most individuals always have difficulty selecting the best ones for pizza that soothes their taste buds.

Since you are here, we don’t want you to go through that dilemma. Below are five (5) of our best BBQ sauce for pizza reviews. Kindly read them and make a profound choice.

Best BBQ Sauces for Pizza

Want to learn more?

Here are our BBQ Sauce for Pizza reviews.

1. BINGOS Original Secret BBQ Sauce

Bingos Original Secret Bbq Sauce

Your pizza will taste better with the BINGOS Original Secret BBQ Sauce. The flavor it gives your pizza is balanced. It is neither too sweet nor very hot. It’s right in the middle. The aroma it adds to the existing aroma of your pizza is incredible. That was a major reason we couldn’t exclude it from this list. It comes in a pack of two 16-oz jars. Luckily, the mouth of the jars is wide enough to allow easy scooping.

No preservatives are included. More so, all the ingredients, including tomato concentrate, distilled vinegar, water, salt, molasses, onion, brown sugar, onion and garlic powders, anchovies, tamarind extract, chili pepper extract, mustard seed, and natural smoke flavor, amongst others, are all-natural. With 16 servings per container and each serving containing only 25 calories, this is a healthy choice for you.

Why do we like it?

  • Gluten-free
  • Dairy and soy-free
  • Great taste
Check Price on Amazon


2. Guy’s Award Winning Sugar-Free BBQ Sauce

Guy's Award Winning Sugar Free Bbq Sauce

If you feel the calories in your pizza are already enough but still want a BBQ sauce to go with it, we recommend the Guy’s Award Winning BBQ sauce. You’ll be getting a variety of 3 different flavors in this pack of three 18-oz bottles of exceptional BBQ sauce for pizza. In addition to the great taste this sauce gives your pizza; you’ll be getting the healthiest BBQ sauce in a bottle. This BBQ sauce is trans-fat-free, sugar-free, gluten-free, contains very low sodium, and very low carbohydrates.

Ingredients mixed to make the Guy’s Award Winning BBQ sauce includes ground cinnamon spices, tomato puree, natural hickory smoke, onions, ground cayenne pepper, cider vinegar, lemon juice from concentrate, modified corn starch, and sucralose, amongst others. 17 servings can be easily gotten from each bottle. Each serving doesn’t contain more than 10 calories, 2g of carbs, and 190mg of sodium.

Why do we like it?

  • Contains no preservatives
  • Great for diabetics
  • Keto-friendly
Check Price on Amazon


3. Rufus Teague Touch O’ Heat BBQ Sauce

Rufus Teague Touch O' Heat Bbq Sauce

The Rufus Teague BBQ Sauce comes in a 16-oz whiskey bottle and offers that extra spiciness you need for your pizza. It has a thick consistency and is made up of high-quality ingredients. These include tomato puree, tamari soy sauce, chipotle pepper, mustard powder, celery seed, garlic powder, orange juice from concentrate, distilled vinegar, and raisin paste, amongst others. This Touch O’ Heat BBQ sauce will go well with your pizza, fish, beef, or pork. No doubt, this is a Kansas City original.

Expect a ‘kinda hot kinda not’ flavor when you apply this BBQ sauce to your pizza. It is with the tasting that you will confirm that it is mouth-watering good. You will conveniently get 13 servings per container, with each serving containing 70 calories. More so, each serving contains 15g of total sugar, 16g of total carbohydrate, and about 370mg of sodium. We like the fact that it also contains calcium, potassium, and iron.

Why do we like it?

  • Non-GMO
  • Certified Kosher
  • No high fructose corn syrup
Check Price on Amazon


4. Gayle’s Sweet ‘N’ Sassy Original BBQ Sauce

Gayle's Sweet 'n' Sassy Original Bbq Sauce

We understand that not every individual likes to purchase small bottles of BBQ sauce for pizza. This includes individuals that have pizza almost every day. The Gayle’s Sweet ‘N’ Sassy Original BBQ sauce comes in a 1-gallon container. The ingredients used in making this sauce are gluten-free. They include tomato puree as a base, brown sugar, distilled vinegar, natural hickory smoke flavor, modified corn starch, black pepper, cayenne pepper, cumin, oregano, and ground mustard seed, amongst others.

We recommend that you refrigerate this 1 gallon (3.79-litres) of sauce after opening so that it stays fresh for longer. While this BBQ sauce contains no extenders and trans fat, you’ll be able to get 127 servings for your pizza. Each serving contains only 30 calories, 8g of carbohydrate, 7g of sugar, and 1g of protein.

Why do we like it?

  • Fat-free
  • Preservatives free
  • Highly versatile
Check Price on Amazon


5. Trader Joe’s Carolina Gold Barbeque Sauce

Trader Joe's Carolina Gold Barbeque Sauce

Mustard-based BBQ sauces always go well with pizza. The Trader Joe’s Carolina Gold Barbeque Sauce is the one you should go for when you need a BBQ sauce for pizza. Don’t be doubtful; this excellent BBQ sauce is also perfect for sandwiches and burgers. Additionally, it can serve as a really great dipping sauce for chicken, vegetables, and fries. The sweet and smoky flavor it offers is outstanding. You’ll love the slight hint of molasses when you take a bite.

Ingredients mixed to make up this sauce includes yellow mustard, cane sugar, Worcestershire sauce, sea salt, molasses, tomato puree, distilled vinegar, natural smoke flavor, and corn starch, amongst others. The Trader Joe’s BBQ Sauce comes in an 18-oz bottle. About 15 servings can be gotten from each bottle, with each serving containing 60 calories, 14g of carbs, 13g of sugar, and about 410mg of sodium.

Why do we like it?

  • Very affordable
  • Smooth, tangy taste
  • No refined oil in it
Check Price on Amazon


BBQ Sauce for Pizza Buyer’s Guide

Do you make your own pizza at home with a pizza oven? Or do you use a pizza pan? If you are tired of canned pizza sauce, you need a great tasting BBQ sauce for pizza. Read our buyer’s guide below for major things to consider when shopping for one.


Do not take the flavor of the BBQ sauce you are about to purchase for granted. It has the power to make or mar your pizza experience. Is it tangy? Is it spicy? Do you like spicy sauces? Does it have a vinegary taste, or does it taste of mustard? It is ideal to buy BBQ sauce for pizza that comes in a pack of 2 or 3 with various flavors to test to ascertain your favorite flavor.


After cutting your pizza with a nice pizza cutter, it is time to smear some BBQ sauce for pizza on it. Ensure that you purchase one with the right texture that suits your preference. While some individuals like it rich and thick, some people like it light but not too watery. The choice is up to you.


Do you know how to defrost pizza properly? If you do, that’s great. If you don’t know how to, then look out for the appearance of the BBQ sauce for pizza that you are going to use on it. If the BBQ sauce bottle looks great and the sauce in it looks delicious, there is every possibility that the BBQ sauce itself will taste awesome. Sometimes the appearance tells it all.