Are you a professional baker or merely a home keeper who loves to bake for pleasure? You will agree that the quality of utensils you use in your kitchen is just as crucial as your baking ingredients. Talented bakers know this to be true; that is why they ensure that they only go for the best quality baking pans that money can buy.
If you do not have experience when it comes to buying baking pans and other kinds of kitchen utensils, you may have a hard time identifying the best baking pan that suits your need. But do not panic; that is what this review is for. We bring to your notice the top 5 best baking pans. No need to spend endless hours surfing through the internet any longer. In this buyer review, you have all the necessary information at your fingertips.
Best Baking Pans
|1. USA Pan 1607CR Baking Pan||99%|
|2. Aluminum Nordic Ware Leakproof Springform Pan||96%|
|3. Wilton Performance Aluminum Pan 9-Inch Round Cake Pans||92%|
|4. OXO Good Grip Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll||89%|
|5. CHEFMADE Baking Sheet Pan||85%|
Want to learn more?
Here are our baking pan reviews.
This extra-large baking pan is ideal for a large family. Providing for many people can be quite a chore if you have a small pan for baking. With the USA Pan 1607CR, you can complete your baking at once without the need to divide your pastries into different trays, which will most certainly take extra time and effort.
For large-scale baking, we understand that size does matter; hence our decision to include this 20 x 14 inches by 1-inch pan. For a pan this size, you can bake significant cookies or even roast a large pile of vegetables.
One great feature of the 1607CR is its non-sticky Americoat coating, which is free of PTFE, PFOA, and BFA. This special coating prevents chemical contamination. What about the baking rack?
Well, it is non-sticky, and it fits into the top of the tray, so you should have no problem lifting it when you are done baking. As for its durability, you have nothing to worry about because it is made of heavy-duty aluminum steel, which is known to be durable, long-lasting, and can withstand extreme heat.
The USA Pan 1607CR is highly recommended for medium and large-sized families that desire to enjoy well-baked foods that are healthy and safe. For an affordable price, this baking pan can be yours.
Why do we like it?
- Can withstand the heat of up to 400° Fahrenheit
- Highly versatile baking pan
- Even heat distribution
- Extra non-sticky baking rack included
Baking can be quite messy, especially when you are baking for so many people. Butter, baking flour, and other ingredients tend to mess up your cooking area no matter how hard you try to prevent this from happening.
Even though you want your food to taste nice at the end of the day, the last thing you want is to leave behind a huge mess that you will end up cleaning soon after.
To prevent this from happening, you need a reliable baking pan that will not leak and cause you problems. Great news, Nordic’ Aluminum Ware Leakproof Springform pan is an anti-mess baking pan.
First of all, it has a leak-proof seal covering the entire surface area to prevent drips and leaks. The edges have a clip system that holds the seal in place, which can be unclipped when you are done.
Another feature that will impress you is that this pan is non-sticky due to the surface coating that repels food. So you can easily wash after use in a matter of minutes.
Lastly, Nordic Leakproof is built to last and ensures that your food comes out with an attractive color.
Why do we like it?
- Easy to assemble
- Sold with a 10-year warranty
- Very durable baking pan
- Anti-drip feature
Wilton Performance Aluminum Pan is excellent for all-round baking, but this pan comes with a special mention for cakes. Lovers of cakes will find this pan reliable because it is specially created for cake baking.
It is designed to give your cake that perfectly round shape you so desire. Some bakers complain of slippage when their cake bakes in the oven, which eventually ruined the shape. With Wilton Aluminum Pan, you wouldn’t have such a problem.
The 9-inch diameter pan has tall edges designed to maintain the cake’s shape. As for heat control, it allows heat to be perfectly distributed all over so that your cake will be well cooked. Besides, the package comes with two pans.
Don’t get us wrong, though. This pan can be used to bake foods of all types, but baking cakes gives you an added advantage in terms of shape and an even distribution of heat, especially when the cake you are baking is large.
Made of top-grade aluminum products, Wilton will last you for several years before the need arises to seek a new replacement.
Why do we like it?
- Anti-warp and anti-rust resistant
- Easy to remove
- Sturdy build
- The perfect cake baker
Nobody desires to spend their hard-earned money on a low-quality product that will fall apart after using it a few times. This is why every single baking pan that made our list this far are of the highest quality with excellent online ratings to back up our claims.
The OXO Good Grip Non-Stick Pan is another high-quality baking pan that can measure up with the other pans on this list.
OXO has long been in the business of delivering high-quality kitchen utensils, and fortunately, their baking pans are known for their durability and peak performance. With this pan, there is no compromise when it comes to quality.
This model, in particular, is extra large for large scale baking. You can bake as many cookies as you want, and you can rest easy knowing that every single one of them will be evenly baked.
The interior has a textured surface that is non-sticky, allowing a free flow of air even while in the oven. The tray is designed with two very thick layers of coatings made with ceramic for extra sturdiness.
The manufacturer has also done a great job in its usability by making it very easy for you to handle. You can easily take your baked pastries even while they are hot.
Why do we like it?
- Easy to clean
- Very thick build
- Made of safe, high-quality aluminum steel
- Anti-scratch coating
Last but not least, on our list of best baking pans is this 17inch CHEFMADE pan. This heavy-duty baking pan is engineered for professional chefs who do a lot of baking. It doesn’t matter whether you bake for a living or your consumption.
We know that you will prefer to buy a pan that you can use 7 days a week, 30 days a month, and 365 days a year. CHEFMADE was one of the best baking pans that we found when scanning the online market for a pan with a guaranteed long-term shelf life.
It is made of Silicon and non-Teflon materials free of PFOA and PTFE. The commercial carbon steel imprint aids heat acceleration, so you can conclude your baking sooner than you expect.
The carbon steel is 0.8mm thick, which prevents warping, so you get the quality you pay for.
We also like CHEFMADE’s high-temperature resistant capacity as this protects your meals from harmful substance contamination and superior non-stick performance. You can remove your food from the pan without the need to use a spatula or any other kind of surgical utensil.
Might we also add that this is a multi-purpose pan for almost any delicacy you can think of. Cakes, Eggs, Meat, Barbecue, Candy, Dessert, and bread. No wonder professional chefs love it.
Why do we like it?
- Fast and even heating
- Very sturdy construction
- Low energy consumption
- Consistent coloring and food formation
Baking Pans Buyer’s Guide
The pan you use for baking has a significant level of impact on the quality of your food. These days, there are so many baking pan brands all competing for buyers’ attention, which can lead to confusion when deciding on the perfect pan to go for.
Knowing what to look out for in a baking pan is very important besides the price. Price is important but is not always an indication of quality. A pan that costs $10 may outperform another that costs three times more.
So you see, pricing and quality are not always mutually inclusive. With that been said, what are some of the things to consider when shopping for a baking pan?
This is the question our buying guide seeks to answer. Find below some of the essential features to take note of when shopping for baking pans. The more of these features the baking pan possesses, the more likely it will serve your purpose and last for a long time.
Here is a list of features to keep a close eye on
Go for the perfect build material
If you do a quick search online, you will find many pans made from different materials, including glass, aluminum, metal, etc. While all these materials may work on some level, they do not offer the same level of quality.
For example, glass ensures even heat distribution but is a fragile piece of hardware. Metal is very durable but highly corrosive. Aluminum, on the other hand, has two significant advantages. It has very durable, and it allows for an even heat distribution, which ensures that your food is properly baked.
Throw into the mix that aluminum is easy to clean, and you have the perfect baking pan at your disposal. When buying baking pans, we advise that you buy aluminum products because of aluminum ticks all the right boxes for durability, ease of maintenance, and even heat distribution.
What is the surface of the pan made of? Is it sticky or non-sticky? Many bakers have gone for baking pans only to realize that they have to spend a lot of time scraping food stuck to the pan.
When you are shopping for a baking pan, we recommend that you always keep your eye open for pans that are non-stick.
Non-sticky pans are easy to wash, and they also last longer. If you make the mistake of buying a pan with a sticky surface, constant scraping and scrubbing will lead to gradual wear and tear. In the not-to-distant future, you may need to buy a new pan. Non-sticky pans last longer and will save you money.
Another thing to look out for is the insulation capacity of the pan. Most advertisers boast that their pans have a high insulation capacity, but this is not always the case. How do you identify a properly insulated pan? It is simple.
Good pans have a layer that separates two metal sheets. This layer allows air to pass through the sheets. They are also slow to absorb temperature and require a longer time in the oven.
But the good thing about them is that when they eventually do a warm-up, they retain heat and even distribute temperature. They also ensure the perfect browning of your food.
The shape does matter if it matters to you. If you are the type who likes your baked foods to be perfectly shaped, you should go for a pan to help you retain your desired shape. Pans with good shape make for a uniform look. Round pans are ideal for cakes. Square or rectangular pans are ideal for small pastries baked in dozens. Just make sure you go for the shape of your choice.
Baking Pan vs. Bakeware sets
Some products come with a single pan, while others are bakeware sets. Before you make a final choice, take a long term view of your baking practice. If you find a pan that suits your needs and will most likely use it for a long time, then go for it.
Some may argue in favor of bakeware sets because they come with different sets that give you more options. While their argument seems valid, what use is a set of baking ware if you are not going to use them?
Bakeware sets cost more but give you more options. Baking pans cost less but give you only a limited option. Both have their advantages, all based on your unique need. So whichever you go for, make sure it suits your need long term.